Game Reviews

[Linkforce]

Oh....well you're an *** Ace!  If you won't read it don't post that you wont read it.

Lol, so then another Mod read it.  

[Moosetroop11]

I read it. I think it's doable. There's about a million things we're trying to get the go ahead for at the moment but I guess there's room for this. If you want the mods to talk about it officially I'll make a thread about it now.

Sounds kinda like Gem's game of the month thing, but I dunno if he's still doing that XD

[Ace of Spades]

I read it. :p I could've sworn we already had a sub forum for game reviews. It was called... Game Reviews (omg). Was it removed when GhostClown left? I'm pretty sure he was the one who lead the operation.

[Linkforce]

Moose: Thanks that would be great!!  Let me know how things go.

Ace:    And yeah that one by Ghostclown is really old and nobody uses it anymore.  Plus that was a thread and I would like this to be a new section.

[GaryCXJk]

Stopped reading when I read Gamespot. Gamespot is a shitsite. It's too biased, even though they occasionally give console games other than those of XBox360 a decent rating. I mean, compare their Ratchet & Clank rating with other sources. Only they dared to give it a **** rating.

[Emerates]

Mayhap other people should be able to review as well, not just the designated team.
You could call it Civilian Review or something.  That way there a lot of different views and opinions out for a single game that people can work with.  Plus, if a complaint about one particular thing keeps coming up in reviews, something can be done about it.  Usually, if one person says something sucks, it's just seen as bitching.  But if a bunch of people are bitching about the same thing, mob rule can be used effectively.

Mayhap.

BTW, I'm still iffy about this idea.  It seems a bit superfluous.  Not many people post their demos here, or so I think.  I could be wrong, though.  I don't get around much.

[aboutasoandthis]

I really like that idea. Maybe the first few who want to review the game together get the job, and if nobody does it this will go to a set team, or something?

As for the game demos they're coming. I've got something planned.

[Ben]

Ive got quest RPG demo, that could use a review.

[Linkforce]

Yeah I got a new demo coming out soon as well.  If this became a new section we could have maybe one sticky thread of reviews by a set "team" of reviewers and then another sticky thread for any casual member reviews.  That could help to eliminate any biased opinions.

[Linkforce]

Any word yet, Mods?

[Meiscool-2]

Can someone write a review for Zelda and the Phantom Hourglass (DS) for me? Cuz I played a bit of it and I didn't really like the intro. I want to know if it gets better or if it pretty much stays the same.

And... if this isn't for reviewing any game... then it should be. Reviews for rpgmaker games should go in the Games forum section, and even then they should probably go in their respective topic rather than a smaller topic with a bunch of reviews in it.

[Ben]

for the record, and slightly off topic, the game of the month for april will be up on friday

[aboutasoandthis]

Originally posted by Meiscool
Can someone write a review for Zelda and the Phantom Hourglass (DS) for me? Cuz I played a bit of it and I didn't really like the intro. I want to know if it gets better or if it pretty much stays the same.

Famitsu gave it a 39/40 so it's supposed to be good...

Originally posted by Meiscool
And... if this isn't for reviewing any game... then it should be. Reviews for rpgmaker games should go in the Games forum section, and even then they should probably go in their respective topic rather than a smaller topic with a bunch of reviews in it.

I think for real games those should just be casual reviews.

[Linkforce]

Yeah this is gonna be just for RM games.

Off Topic: Maybe we could have a sub forum for actual game reviews..........  lol

[Archem]

Originally posted by Meiscool
Can someone write a review for Zelda and the Phantom Hourglass (DS) for me? Cuz I played a bit of it and I didn't really like the intro. I want to know if it gets better or if it pretty much stays the same.

Great game. End of story.